G = Gluten friendly upon request (up-charge)
V = Vegetarian Friendly upon request
* Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness.
Jump to sections:
| Starters |
|---|
| Side Baskets Baskets of our chips, fries, curly fries, tots, broasted potatoes, or sweet potato fries. G $5.00 |
| Stache Wings Our signature house wings. Choose from our bold flavored sauces: Parmesan Garlic • Teriyaki • Bourbon • BBQ • Sweet Chili • Honey Mustard • Ranchacha (Dry Rub) • Honey Sriracha • Spicy Garlic Ranch • Mango Habañero • Big Sexy• Citrus Chipoltle BBQ • Buffalo • Five Pepper Death Punch Try our same delicious wings finished on the grill, just the way Papa loves them. Order them “Papas Way.” 6 Wings…$8.00 12 Wings…$14.00 6 Boneless Wings…$8.00 12 Boneless Wings…$14.00 Served with celery, carrots, & one side of Ranch or Bleu Cheese. (Each Additional Sauce…$0.50) |
| Tower of Tortillas Hand cut tortillas loaded with our Cheddar and Jack cheeses, pico de gallo, & black olives. Served with a side of salsa & loaded sour cream. GV $9.75 Add beef, chicken, or steak for $3 more. |
| Ultimate Tower Our hand cut tortillas loaded with our house smoked pulled pork, caramelized onions, bleu cheese & coleslaw. $12.75 |
| Garlic Bread Classic garlic bread loaded with seasoned butter and parmesan cheese. Served with marinara. $9.25 Top with mozzarella cheese for $2 more! V |
| Cheese Curds Our famous Wisconsin cheese curd trio of cheddar, bacon, & jalapeño curds served with a side of Southwest, marinara, or ranch sauce. $9.50 |
| Spin Dip House made spinach & artichoke dip, baked golden brown & served with house made tortilla chips. $10.75 |
| *Quesadillas Large grilled tortilla filled with shredded cheddar & Jack cheese, pico de gallo, & served with salsa & sour cream. V $9.75 Add $3 for Chicken, steak or Beef to satisfy your inner carnivore. |
| Giant Pretzel Try one of Papa’s favorites! A traditional giant soft pretzel brought to us by the Milwaukee Pretzel Company. Served with our house made beer cheese, nacho cheese dip, or spicy honey mustard. $13.00 |
| Guac & Chips Freshly made guacamole served with a basket of our hand cut tortillas. $9.50 |
| Salsa Trio This trio includes a bright salsa verde, a sweet pineapple pico de gallo, & a spicy salsa roja. Served with a basket of our seasoned hand cut tortilla chips. $7.50 |
| Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts Sticky & sweet sauce baked into smoky bacon, wrapped around crunchy water chestnuts. Yum! $11.50 |
| Bacon Chicken Bites Tender bites of chicken wrapped in crispy applewood smoked bacon, coated in our bourbon glaze! Served with a side of our house made ranch. $11.50 |
| Adult Chicken Tenders 6-piece chicken tenders fried golden brown and served with your choice of chips, fries or curly fries. $13.00 Add $2 for sweet potato fries, tater tots, or broasted potatoes. |
| Jalapeño Poppers Crispy breaded cream cheese & jalapeño bites. Served with a side of our house made ranch to dip. $10.00 |
| Fried Eggplant Breaded sliced eggplant fried golden brown. Served with a side of marinara sauce to dip. $11.50 |
| Mac & Cheese Bites Eight golden bites filled with macaroni & bended cheedar cheeses. Served with a side of our house made ranch. $9.50 |
| Mexican Street Corn Dip Traditional Mexican street corn flavors transformed into the creamiest corn-filled dip. Served with a basket of our hand cut tortilla chips. $11.50 |
| Backyard Garden |
|---|
| Served with a Homemade Breadstick & your choice of dressing. Ranch • Balsamic Vinaigrette • Italian • French • Caesar • Oil & Vinegar • Bleu Cheese • 1000 Island • Southwest |
| House Salad Crisp mixed greens, cucumbers, tomato, green peppers, sliced red onion, shredded carrots, cheese & house croutons. GV Side…$6.75 Large…$8.50 Add grilled chicken breast for $3 or grilled steak for $6 more |
| Chicken Salad Your choice of blackened chicken breast, broasted chicken fillet, or a grilled chicken breast on a bed of mixed greens topped with bacon, cheddar, tomatoes & sliced red onions. $11.50 |
| Classic Caesar Chopped romaine tossed with our fresh house made Caesar dressing, house made garlic crusted croutons, & shaved parmesan cheese. $9.50 Add grilled chicken for $3 or grilled steak for $6 more. |
| Taco Salad Seasoned ground beef, fiesta blended cheeses, and Pico de Gallo on a bed of mixed greens and served with a sour cream, tortilla chips and your choice of salsa Verde, sweet pineapple Pico, or spicy salsa Roja. $11.50 |
| Steak Lovers Salad Tender strips of our grilled steak on a bed of mixed greens, mandarin orange, red onion, tomatoes, & sliced avocado. $15.00 |
| Soup (Seasonal) |
|---|
| Soup of the day Our chefs love to create a variety of different soups! Ask your server what soup we are featuring today! Your choice of a cup or a bowl! Cup…$6.00 Bowl…$7.00 |
| Skillets & Pastas |
|---|
| Gluten Free Pasta available upon request. |
| Sexy Mac & Cheese Three cheese pasta loaded in a packed iron skillet with pulled pork & our Big Sexy sauce topped with golden panko breadcrumbs & then baked to perfection. $13.50 |
| Skillet Mac & Cheese Three cheese pasta loaded in a packed iron skillet w/ andouille sausage & bacon topped with golden panko breadcrumbs & then baked to golden perfection. $13.50 |
| Chicken Alfredo Creamy house made alfredo sauce served with linguine pasta topped with sliced grilled chicken breast & parmesan cheese. $14.50 Substitute Grilled Steak for $3 more. |
| Kid’s Menu |
|---|
| All Kid’s Meals include a side of chips or fries – $8.00 |
| Cheese Pizza • Pepperoni Pizza • Sausage Pizza • Mac & Cheese • Chicken Tenders • Grilled Cheese • Mini Corndogs |
| That’s a Wrap! |
|---|
| All wraps are served in a large flour tortilla with your choice of hand cut fries, curly fries, or our house made chips. Tots or sweet potato fries for $2 more. Add house side salad or cup of soup for $4 more. PLEASE ORDER SIDE SAUCES WHEN PLACING YOUR ORDER. |
| Buffalo Chicken Wrap Grilled chicken breast, mixed greens, diced tomato, sliced red onion, cheddar jack cheese, & our homemade buffalo ranch sauce. $12.00 |
| Grilled Chicken Wrap Grilled chicken breast, mixed greens, diced tomato, sliced red onion, bacon, & garlic mayo. $12.00 |
| Pesto Chicken Wrap Your choice of grilled or broasted chicken breast, mixed greens, provolone cheese, & finished with sweet basil pesto & mayo. $12.50 |
| Southwest Grilled Chicken w/ Avocado Wrap Grilled chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, avocado, mixed greens, & our Southwest chipotle mayo. $12.50 |
| “Jump the Border” Wrap Grilled steak strips, mixed greens, sliced red onion, green pepper, queso fresco, & our Southwest dressing. $13.50 |
| Chicken Caesar Wrap Grilled chicken, chopped romaine lettuce, house made garlic crushed croutons, parmesan cheese, & fresh house made Caesar dressing. $12.50 |
| Pizza |
|---|
| Gluten free crust is available for additional charge. |
| The Hawaiian Hammer Classic toppings of pineapple and ham. Training Wheel…$14.00 12”…$16.00 14”…$18.00 |
| The “PMS” Topped w/ pepperoni, mushroom and sausage for a feisty bite. Training Wheel…$15.00 12”…$17.00 14”…$19.00 |
| The Porker Our house smoked bbq pork, sliced red onions, both cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, & finished with a BBQ sauce drizzle. Guaranteed to fill any piggy up. Training Wheel…$15.00 12”…$17.00 14”…$19.00 |
| Buffalo Chicken Our breaded boneless buffalo wings, cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese, diced tomato, sliced red onion, & finished with buffalo & ranch drizzle. Want a kick? Add jalapeños. Training Wheel…$15.00 12”…$17.00 14”…$19.00 |
| Create Your Own Put your imagination to action and build your own signature pizza just the way you like it. Two toppings of your choice included. Training Wheel…$14.00 12”…$16.00 14”…$18.00 |
| Toppings: Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Sliced Red Onions, Mushrooms, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Black Olives, Green Olives, Chicken, Jalapeños, Pineapple, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Ranch Drizzle, Ground Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Taco Meat. Additional Toppings Each: Training Wheel… $1.00 12″… $1.25 14″…$1.50 Additional Premium Toppings: Mac & Cheese: TW-$3, 12”-$4, 14”-$5 Shredded Smoked Pork: TW-$3, 12”-$4, 14”-$5 |
| Sammies |
|---|
| Served with your choice of hand cut fries,
curly fries, or house made chips. $2 upcharge for sweet potato fries, tots, or broasted potatoes. $3 upcharge for side salad or cup of soup. $2 upcharge for gluten free bun. PLEASE ORDER SIDE SAUCES WHEN PLACING YOUR ORDER. |
| *Mary’s Open Faced Burger 1/3 lb. Steak burger topped w/ pesto, fried mozzarella, basil, sliced red onion, & shredded parmesan on garlic buttered Texas Toast. $14.00 |
| *BIG Sexy Burger Our signature 1/3 lb. Steak burger topped w/ bacon, our 3-cheese blend, jalapeños, jack straw onions, & our signature Big Sexy sauce on a toasted. $14.00 |
| *The Old School 1/3 lb. Steak burger with bacon, cheddar, tomato, lettuce, & bbq mayo on a toasted bun. $14.00 |
| Southern Bell Grilled chicken breast topped with Jack straw onions, Pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, sliced tomato, chipotle mayo and served on a toasted hoagie. $15.00 |
| Bye Bye Babe House smoked BBQ pork piled high on grilled Texas toast. Loaded with cheddar, Big Sexy sauce & coleslaw. $14.00 Want something simpler? We can make a plain bbq pork sandwich on our Texas toast for $11.00 |
| *The Hangover A steak burger grilled on a toasted bun, with smoked bacon, caramelized onions, & pepper jack cheese. Topped with a fried egg & BIG sexy sauce. $14.00 |
| Papa’s BLT Toasted Texas toast brushed with sriracha mayo, loaded with smoked bacon, lettuce, & tomato. $13.00 |
| *Philly Cheese Steak Thinly sliced ribeye steak, grilled with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, shredded mozzarella, served on a toasted French roll. Served with a side of au jus. $15.00 |
| Steak Sandwich A grilled sirloin steak sandwich topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions and served on a hoagie and your choice of fries, curly fries, or chips. $15.00 |
| Grown Up Grilled Cheese A classic favorite spruced up! Pepper jack, cheddar, & American cheeses, with bacon sandwiched between two slices of Texas toast & grilled to perfection.. $12.00 Add Jalapeno poppers for $2 more. |
| “Make Burgers Great Again” Signature 1/3 lb. steak burger topped with mushrooms, swiss cheese, & bacon. $14.00 |
| Broasted Chicken Sandwich Broasted chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onion, & mayo served on a brioche bun. $15.00 Add your choice of cheese for $1 more. |
| Broasted Pork Chop Sandwich Broasted pork chop, lettuce, tomato, onion, & mayo served on a brioche bun $15.00 Add your choice of cheese for $1 more. |
| O’Kelly A classic Reuben sandwich of thinly sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and 1000 island dressing grilled between two slices of rye bread. $15.00 |
| Fish Sandwich Breaded white fish fillet on a toasted brioche bun w/tomato, lettuce, pickles, & American cheese. Served with a side of our homemade tartar sauce. $10.00 |
| Loaded Tots |
|---|
| Buffalo Chicken Tots Buffalo chicken, house cheddar cheese, diced tomato, red onion, & jalapeños served in a skillet full of our golden tots with a Buffalo Ranch drizzle. $12.00 |
| Ultimate Tots Our house smoked pulled pork, caramelized onions, bleu cheese, & coleslaw drizzled with our Big Sexy sauce & served in a skillet full of our golden tots. $12.00 |
| Philly Tots Golden tots loaded with thinly sliced ribeye steak, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & shredded mozzarella cheese. $13.00 |
| Genuine Broaster Chicken |
|---|
| (Please allow extra time for broasting) Add Served with your choice of hand cut fries, curly fries or house made chips. $2 upcharge for sweet potato fries, tots or broasted potatoes. $3 upcharge for side salad or cup of soup. |
| 1/2 Broasted Chicken Served with choice of potato, coleslaw, and biscuit. $16.50 |
| 8pc. Broasted Chicken Served with 2 biscuits and 2 sides of coleslaw. Side potato not included. $20.00 |
| 2pc. Broasted Chicken Your choice of breast & wing (white meat) or thigh & leg (dark meat). Served with a choice of potato, coleslaw, & a biscuit. $12.00 $14.00 for all white meat. |
| Desserts |
|---|
| Homemade rotating dessert specialties! Ask your server for the dessert of the day as well as that dessert’s price! |
Weekly Specials
| Taco Tuesday |
|---|
| Every Tuesday our chefs create a Mexican dish. Also, ask your bartender or server about the drink specials that pair with it! |
| Wing Wednesday |
|---|
| Ask your server/bartender for the current prices/specials. Papa’s Way not offered for special pricing. |
| Fridays Catch! |
|---|
| ONLY served on Fridays. Served with your choice of hand cut fries, curly fries, or house made chips. Tots or sweet potato fries – add $2. Potato pancakes – add $3 |
| Fish Sandwich Breaded white fish fillet on a toasted brioche bun w/tomato, lettuce, pickles, & American cheese. Served with a side of our homemade tartar sauce. $10.00 |
| Hand Battered Cod Beer battered fillets fried golden brown, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge. $11.00 |
| Breaded Perch Breaded fillets fried golden brown, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge. $12.00 |
| Breaded Shrimp Ten panko breaded shrimp fried golden brown, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & cocktail sauce. $14.00 |
| Baked Cod Tender cod fillets baked in a buttery white wine sauce served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge. $11.00 |
| Walleye One large walleye fillet beer battered & deep fried to perfection, served with coleslaw, tartar sauce, rye bread & lemon wedge. $17.00 |
| Potato Pancakes Two homemade potato pancakes served with applesauce or syrup! $3.00 |
Beverages
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
Coffee
Hot Chocolate
Sweet Tea
Iced Tea
Lemonade
7-Up
Cherry Coke
Coke
Diet Coke
Diet 7 Up
Dr. Pepper
Ginger Ale
Ginger Beer
Mountain Dew
Diet Mountain Dew
Red Bull
Sugar Free Red Bull
Sprecher Cream Soda
Sprecher Orange Dream
Sprecher Root Beer
Non-Alcoholic Beer
Michelob Ultra Zero
Athletic IPA N/A
Lakefront Riverwest Stein N/A
Guiness 0
Tap Beer
Our taps rotate! Please ask your bartender or server what we have on tap now!
Beer, Ciders, and Seltzers
Alaskan Amber
Angry Orchard G
Blue Moon
Bud Light
Bud Light Lime
Budweiser
Busch Light
Carbliss
Coors Light
Corona
Corona Light
Corona Premier
Hacker Pschorr
Heineken
High Noon
Lakefront IPA
Lakefront Riverwest Stein
Michelob Ultra
Mikes Lemonade
Miller Extra Light
Miller Highlife
Miller Lite
Modelo
New Glarus Spotted Cow
New Grist GF
Nutrl
Pabst
Redbridge GF
Redds Apple Ale
Stella Artois
Surfside
Too Turnt Tea
Twisted Tea
White Claw
